One of the best horror novels in recent memory is begging for a movie adaptation. It's a unique blend of medieval-set fantasy and horror, set against the backdrop of the Black Death in 14th-century France. The novel, titled 'Between Two Fires' by Christopher Buehlman, is a gripping tale that has slowly risen from obscurity to become a modern classic. It's a story that not only captures the terror of the plague but also the superstitions and religious fears of the time, making it a perfect candidate for a cinematic adaptation.
The novel follows Thomas, a disgraced knight turned brigand, and Delphine, a young girl who claims to have holy visions. Together, they embark on a quest to bring Delphine to the holy city of Avignon, where the Pope resides. Buehlman's writing is witty and vivid, painting a world that is both a joy and a terror to explore. The story is structured like a collection of medieval monster tales, with a wide variety of demons and supernatural elements that will keep readers on the edge of their seats.
What makes 'Between Two Fires' particularly fascinating is its exploration of the supernatural within the context of the Black Death. The plague is not just a disease brought by rats; it's a curse cast upon humanity by demons. Buehlman intertwines a war between Heaven and Hell with the mortal plane, creating a terrifying and complex narrative. The novel's portrayal of the plague as a divine punishment mirrors the beliefs of uneducated peasants in 14th-century France, adding a layer of psychological depth to the story.
One of the creepiest chapters, 'Of the Ones Who Knock by Night', showcases Buehlman's ability to craft chilling moments. Thomas and Delphine encounter demons in Paris, who use holy statues as corporeal forms to kill unsuspecting people. This scene is a testament to the author's skill in blending historical fears with supernatural elements.
In my opinion, the director Robert Eggers, known for his horror period pieces like 'The Witch', would be the ideal choice to adapt 'Between Two Fires'. Eggers' films, like 'The Witch', delve into the superstitions and beliefs of their respective eras, making them feel incredibly authentic. 'Between Two Fires' shares this approach, taking the fears of 14th-century France and weaving them into a terrifying narrative.
The novel's popularity, as noted by author Joe Hill in the foreword to the 2026 edition, can be attributed to its enduring appeal. After the COVID-19 pandemic, readers could relate to the idea of living in a plague-filled world, but Buehlman's masterful storytelling also contributes to its success. The book's epic quest of redemption and the presence of infernal monsters make it a compelling choice for Hollywood.
In conclusion, 'Between Two Fires' is a masterpiece of horror and fantasy, blending historical context with supernatural elements. Its rich narrative, complex characters, and exploration of human fears make it a strong contender for a movie adaptation. With its rising popularity and critical acclaim, it's only a matter of time before this novel gets the cinematic treatment it deserves.
